tbl1 = [{"variable":"Total","Var":"Counts","values":850085.0,"year":2010.0},{"variable":"Total","Var":"Percentages","values":1.0,"year":2010.0},{"variable":"Doctor of Medicine (M.D.)","Var":"Counts","values":789788.0,"year":2010.0},{"variable":"Doctor of Medicine (M.D.)","Var":"Percentages","values":0.929,"year":2010.0},{"variable":"Doctor of Osteopathic Medicine (D.O.)","Var":"Counts","values":58329.0,"year":2010.0},{"variable":"Doctor of Osteopathic Medicine (D.O.)","Var":"Percentages","values":0.069,"year":2010.0},{"variable":"Unknown Degree","Var":"Counts","values":1968.0,"year":2010.0},{"variable":"Unknown Degree","Var":"Percentages","values":0.002,"year":2010.0},{"variable":"United States Medical Graduates (M.D. or D.O.) and Canadian Graduates","Var":"Counts","values":641815.0,"year":2010.0},{"variable":"United States Medical Graduates (M.D. or D.O.) and Canadian Graduates","Var":"Percentages","values":0.755,"year":2010.0},{"variable":"International Medical Graduates","Var":"Counts","values":188402.0,"year":2010.0},{"variable":"International Medical Graduates","Var":"Percentages","values":0.222,"year":2010.0},{"variable":"Unknown Medical School","Var":"Counts","values":19868.0,"year":2010.0},{"variable":"Unknown Medical School","Var":"Percentages","values":0.023,"year":2010.0},{"variable":"Less than 30 years","Var":"Counts","values":16285.0,"year":2010.0},{"variable":"Less than 30 years","Var":"Percentages","values":0.019,"year":2010.0},{"variable":"30–39 years","Var":"Counts","values":193267.0,"year":2010.0},{"variable":"30–39 years","Var":"Percentages","values":0.22699999999999999,"year":2010.0},{"variable":"40–49 years","Var":"Counts","values":210196.0,"year":2010.0},{"variable":"40–49 years","Var":"Percentages","values":0.247,"year":2010.0},{"variable":"50–59 years","Var":"Counts","values":207129.0,"year":2010.0},{"variable":"50–59 years","Var":"Percentages","values":0.244,"year":2010.0},{"variable":"60–69 years","Var":"Counts","values":125385.0,"year":2010.0},{"variable":"60–69 years","Var":"Percentages","values":0.14800000000000003,"year":2010.0},{"variable":"70 + years","Var":"Counts","values":64717.0,"year":2010.0},{"variable":"70 + years","Var":"Percentages","values":0.076,"year":2010.0},{"variable":"Unknown Age","Var":"Counts","values":33106.0,"year":2010.0},{"variable":"Unknown Age","Var":"Percentages","values":0.039,"year":2010.0},{"variable":"Male","Var":"Counts","values":568501.0,"year":2010.0},{"variable":"Male","Var":"Percentages","values":0.669,"year":2010.0},{"variable":"Female","Var":"Counts","values":246314.0,"year":2010.0},{"variable":"Female","Var":"Percentages","values":0.29,"year":2010.0},{"variable":"Unknown Sex","Var":"Counts","values":35270.0,"year":2010.0},{"variable":"Unknown Sex","Var":"Percentages","values":0.040999999999999998,"year":2010.0},{"variable":"Yes","Var":"Counts","values":633733.0,"year":2010.0},{"variable":"Yes","Var":"Percentages","values":0.745,"year":2010.0},{"variable":"No","Var":"Counts","values":216352.0,"year":2010.0},{"variable":"No","Var":"Percentages","values":0.255,"year":2010.0},{"variable":"1","Var":"Counts","values":657208.0,"year":2010.0},{"variable":"1","Var":"Percentages","values":0.773,"year":2010.0},{"variable":"2","Var":"Counts","values":142423.0,"year":2010.0},{"variable":"2","Var":"Percentages","values":0.168,"year":2010.0},{"variable":"3 or more","Var":"Counts","values":50454.0,"year":2010.0},{"variable":"3 or more","Var":"Percentages","values":0.059000000000000007,"year":2010.0},{"variable":"Total","Var":"Counts","values":878194.0,"year":2012.0},{"variable":"Total","Var":"Percentages","values":1.0,"year":2012.0},{"variable":"Doctor of Medicine (M.D.)","Var":"Counts","values":812019.0,"year":2012.0},{"variable":"Doctor of Medicine (M.D.)","Var":"Percentages","values":0.925,"year":2012.0},{"variable":"Doctor of Osteopathic Medicine (D.O.)","Var":"Counts","values":63045.0,"year":2012.0},{"variable":"Doctor of Osteopathic Medicine (D.O.)","Var":"Percentages","values":0.07200000000000001,"year":2012.0},{"variable":"Unknown Degree","Var":"Counts","values":3130.0,"year":2012.0},{"variable":"Unknown Degree","Var":"Percentages","values":0.004,"year":2012.0},{"variable":"United States Medical Graduates (M.D. or D.O.) and Canadian Graduates","Var":"Counts","values":661996.0,"year":2012.0},{"variable":"United States Medical Graduates (M.D. or D.O.) and Canadian Graduates","Var":"Percentages","values":0.754,"year":2012.0},{"variable":"International Medical Graduates","Var":"Counts","values":196573.0,"year":2012.0},{"variable":"International Medical Graduates","Var":"Percentages","values":0.22399999999999999,"year":2012.0},{"variable":"Unknown Medical School","Var":"Counts","values":19625.0,"year":2012.0},{"variable":"Unknown Medical School","Var":"Percentages","values":0.022000000000000003,"year":2012.0},{"variable":"Less than 30 years","Var":"Counts","values":12047.0,"year":2012.0},{"variable":"Less than 30 years","Var":"Percentages","values":0.013999999999999999,"year":2012.0},{"variable":"30–39 years",
"Var":"Counts","values":182536.0,"year":2012.0},{"variable":"30–39 years","Var":"Percentages","values":0.20800000000000003,"year":2012.0},{"variable":"40–49 years","Var":"Counts","values":216234.0,"year":2012.0},{"variable":"40–49 years","Var":"Percentages","values":0.24600000000000003,"year":2012.0},{"variable":"50–59 years","Var":"Counts","values":214936.0,"year":2012.0},{"variable":"50–59 years","Var":"Percentages","values":0.245,"year":2012.0},{"variable":"60–69 years","Var":"Counts","values":152175.0,"year":2012.0},{"variable":"60–69 years","Var":"Percentages","values":0.17300000000000002,"year":2012.0},{"variable":"70 + years","Var":"Counts","values":78794.0,"year":2012.0},{"variable":"70 + years","Var":"Percentages","values":0.09,"year":2012.0},{"variable":"Unknown Age","Var":"Counts","values":21472.0,"year":2012.0},{"variable":"Unknown Age","Var":"Percentages","values":0.024,"year":2012.0},{"variable":"Male","Var":"Counts","values":578478.0,"year":2012.0},{"variable":"Male","Var":"Percentages","values":0.659,"year":2012.0},{"variable":"Female","Var":"Counts","values":264846.0,"year":2012.0},{"variable":"Female","Var":"Percentages","values":0.302,"year":2012.0},{"variable":"Unknown Sex","Var":"Counts","values":34870.0,"year":2012.0},{"variable":"Unknown Sex","Var":"Percentages","values":0.04,"year":2012.0},{"variable":"Yes","Var":"Counts","values":671755.0,"year":2012.0},{"variable":"Yes","Var":"Percentages","values":0.765,"year":2012.0},{"variable":"No","Var":"Counts","values":206439.0,"year":2012.0},{"variable":"No","Var":"Percentages","values":0.235,"year":2012.0},{"variable":"1","Var":"Counts","values":688781.0,"year":2012.0},{"variable":"1","Var":"Percentages","values":0.784,"year":2012.0},{"variable":"2","Var":"Counts","values":138274.0,"year":2012.0},{"variable":"2","Var":"Percentages","values":0.157,"year":2012.0},{"variable":"3 or more","Var":"Counts","values":51139.0,"year":2012.0},{"variable":"3 or more","Var":"Percentages","values":0.057999999999999999,"year":2012.0},{"variable":"Total","Var":"Counts","values":916264.0,"year":2014.0},{"variable":"Total","Var":"Percentages","values":1.0,"year":2014.0},{"variable":"Doctor of Medicine (M.D.)","Var":"Counts","values":841321.0,"year":2014.0},{"variable":"Doctor of Medicine (M.D.)","Var":"Percentages","values":0.9179999999999999,"year":2014.0},{"variable":"Doctor of Osteopathic Medicine (D.O.)","Var":"Counts","values":72961.0,"year":2014.0},{"variable":"Doctor of Osteopathic Medicine (D.O.)","Var":"Percentages","values":0.08,"year":2014.0},{"variable":"Unknown Degree","Var":"Counts","values":1982.0,"year":2014.0},{"variable":"Unknown Degree","Var":"Percentages","values":0.002,"year":2014.0},{"variable":"United States Medical Graduates (M.D. or D.O.) and Canadian Graduates","Var":"Counts","values":687187.0,"year":2014.0},{"variable":"United States Medical Graduates (M.D. or D.O.) and Canadian Graduates","Var":"Percentages","values":0.75,"year":2014.0},{"variable":"International Medical Graduates","Var":"Counts","values":207840.0,"year":2014.0},{"variable":"International Medical Graduates","Var":"Percentages","values":0.22699999999999999,"year":2014.0},{"variable":"Unknown Medical School","Var":"Counts","values":21237.0,"year":2014.0},{"variable":"Unknown Medical School","Var":"Percentages","values":0.023,"year":2014.0},{"variable":"Less than 30 years","Var":"Counts","values":7025.0,"year":2014.0},{"variable":"Less than 30 years","Var":"Percentages","values":0.008,"year":2014.0},{"variable":"30–39 years","Var":"Counts","values":181452.0,"year":2014.0},{"variable":"30–39 years","Var":"Percentages","values":0.198,"year":2014.0},{"variable":"40–49 years","Var":"Counts","values":223472.0,"year":2014.0},{"variable":"40–49 years","Var":"Percentages","values":0.244,"year":2014.0},{"variable":"50–59 years","Var":"Counts","values":216643.0,"year":2014.0},{"variable":"50–59 years","Var":"Percentages","values":0.23600000000000002,"year":2014.0},{"variable":"60–69 years","Var":"Counts","values":182918.0,"year":2014.0},{"variable":"60–69 years","Var":"Percentages","values":0.2,"year":2014.0},{"variable":"70 + years","Var":"Counts","values":99554.0,"year":2014.0},{"variable":"70 + years","Var":"Percentages","values":0.109,"year":2014.0},{"variable":"Unknown Age","Var":"Counts","values":5200.0,"year":2014.0},{"variable":"Unknown Age","Var":"Percentages","values":0.006,"year":2014.0},{"variable":"Male","Var":"Counts","values":604926.0,"year":2014.0},{"variable":"Male","Var":"Percentages","values":0.66,"year":2014.0},{"variable":"Female","Var":"Counts","values":293565.0,"year":2014.0},{"variable":"Female","Var":"Percentages","values":0.32,"year":2014.0},{"variable":"Unknown Sex","Var":"Counts","values":17773.0,"year":2014.0
},{"variable":"Unknown Sex","Var":"Percentages","values":0.019,"year":2014.0},{"variable":"Yes","Var":"Counts","values":724919.0,"year":2014.0},{"variable":"Yes","Var":"Percentages","values":0.7909999999999999,"year":2014.0},{"variable":"No","Var":"Counts","values":191345.0,"year":2014.0},{"variable":"No","Var":"Percentages","values":0.209,"year":2014.0},{"variable":"1","Var":"Counts","values":720599.0,"year":2014.0},{"variable":"1","Var":"Percentages","values":0.7859999999999999,"year":2014.0},{"variable":"2","Var":"Counts","values":142023.0,"year":2014.0},{"variable":"2","Var":"Percentages","values":0.155,"year":2014.0},{"variable":"3 or more","Var":"Counts","values":53642.0,"year":2014.0},{"variable":"3 or more","Var":"Percentages","values":0.059000000000000007,"year":2014.0},{"variable":"Total","Var":"Counts","values":953695.0,"year":2016.0},{"variable":"Total","Var":"Percentages","values":1.0,"year":2016.0},{"variable":"Doctor of Medicine (M.D.)","Var":"Counts","values":870312.0,"year":2016.0},{"variable":"Doctor of Medicine (M.D.)","Var":"Percentages","values":0.9129999999999999,"year":2016.0},{"variable":"Doctor of Osteopathic Medicine (D.O.)","Var":"Counts","values":81115.0,"year":2016.0},{"variable":"Doctor of Osteopathic Medicine (D.O.)","Var":"Percentages","values":0.085,"year":2016.0},{"variable":"Unknown Degree","Var":"Counts","values":2268.0,"year":2016.0},{"variable":"Unknown Degree","Var":"Percentages","values":0.002,"year":2016.0},{"variable":"United States Medical Graduates (M.D. or D.O.) and Canadian Graduates","Var":"Counts","values":724640.0,"year":2016.0},{"variable":"United States Medical Graduates (M.D. or D.O.) and Canadian Graduates","Var":"Percentages","values":0.76,"year":2016.0},{"variable":"International Medical Graduates","Var":"Counts","values":216182.0,"year":2016.0},{"variable":"International Medical Graduates","Var":"Percentages","values":0.22699999999999999,"year":2016.0},{"variable":"Unknown Medical School","Var":"Counts","values":12873.0,"year":2016.0},{"variable":"Unknown Medical School","Var":"Percentages","values":0.013000000000000002,"year":2016.0},{"variable":"Less than 30 years","Var":"Counts","values":18023.0,"year":2016.0},{"variable":"Less than 30 years","Var":"Percentages","values":0.019,"year":2016.0},{"variable":"30–39 years","Var":"Counts","values":208799.0,"year":2016.0},{"variable":"30–39 years","Var":"Percentages","values":0.21899999999999998,"year":2016.0},{"variable":"40–49 years","Var":"Counts","values":227953.0,"year":2016.0},{"variable":"40–49 years","Var":"Percentages","values":0.239,"year":2016.0},{"variable":"50–59 years","Var":"Counts","values":214422.0,"year":2016.0},{"variable":"50–59 years","Var":"Percentages","values":0.225,"year":2016.0},{"variable":"60–69 years","Var":"Counts","values":183870.0,"year":2016.0},{"variable":"60–69 years","Var":"Percentages","values":0.193,"year":2016.0},{"variable":"70 + years","Var":"Counts","values":94969.0,"year":2016.0},{"variable":"70 + years","Var":"Percentages","values":0.1,"year":2016.0},{"variable":"Unknown Age","Var":"Counts","values":5659.0,"year":2016.0},{"variable":"Unknown Age","Var":"Percentages","values":0.006,"year":2016.0},{"variable":"Male","Var":"Counts","values":617186.0,"year":2016.0},{"variable":"Male","Var":"Percentages","values":0.647,"year":2016.0},{"variable":"Female","Var":"Counts","values":319145.0,"year":2016.0},{"variable":"Female","Var":"Percentages","values":0.335,"year":2016.0},{"variable":"Unknown Sex","Var":"Counts","values":17364.0,"year":2016.0},{"variable":"Unknown Sex","Var":"Percentages","values":0.018000000000000003,"year":2016.0},{"variable":"Yes","Var":"Counts","values":752558.0,"year":2016.0},{"variable":"Yes","Var":"Percentages","values":0.789,"year":2016.0},{"variable":"No","Var":"Counts","values":201137.0,"year":2016.0},{"variable":"No","Var":"Percentages","values":0.21100000000000003,"year":2016.0},{"variable":"1","Var":"Counts","values":746417.0,"year":2016.0},{"variable":"1","Var":"Percentages","values":0.7829999999999999,"year":2016.0},{"variable":"2","Var":"Counts","values":148250.0,"year":2016.0},{"variable":"2","Var":"Percentages","values":0.155,"year":2016.0},{"variable":"3 or more","Var":"Counts","values":59028.0,"year":2016.0},{"variable":"3 or more","Var":"Percentages","values":0.062,"year":2016.0},{"variable":"Total","Var":"Counts","values":985026.0,"year":2018.0},{"variable":"Total","Var":"Percentages","values":1.0,"year":2018.0},{"variable":"Doctor of Medicine (M.D.)","Var":"Counts","values":892583.0,"year":2018.0},{"variable":"Doctor of Medicine (M.D.)","Var":"Percentages","values":0.9059999999999999,"year":2018.0},{"variable":"Doctor of Osteopathic Medicine (D.O.)","Var":"Counts","values":89764.0,"year":2018.0},
{"variable":"Doctor of Osteopathic Medicine (D.O.)","Var":"Percentages","values":0.091,"year":2018.0},{"variable":"Unknown Degree","Var":"Counts","values":2679.0,"year":2018.0},{"variable":"Unknown Degree","Var":"Percentages","values":0.003,"year":2018.0},{"variable":"United States Medical Graduates (M.D. or D.O.) and Canadian Graduates","Var":"Counts","values":748398.0,"year":2018.0},{"variable":"United States Medical Graduates (M.D. or D.O.) and Canadian Graduates","Var":"Percentages","values":0.76,"year":2018.0},{"variable":"International Medical Graduates","Var":"Counts","values":222708.0,"year":2018.0},{"variable":"International Medical Graduates","Var":"Percentages","values":0.226,"year":2018.0},{"variable":"Unknown Medical School","Var":"Counts","values":13920.0,"year":2018.0},{"variable":"Unknown Medical School","Var":"Percentages","values":0.013999999999999999,"year":2018.0},{"variable":"Less than 30 years","Var":"Counts","values":16250.0,"year":2018.0},{"variable":"Less than 30 years","Var":"Percentages","values":0.016,"year":2018.0},{"variable":"30–39 years","Var":"Counts","values":219711.0,"year":2018.0},{"variable":"30–39 years","Var":"Percentages","values":0.223,"year":2018.0},{"variable":"40–49 years","Var":"Counts","values":233192.0,"year":2018.0},{"variable":"40–49 years","Var":"Percentages","values":0.237,"year":2018.0},{"variable":"50–59 years","Var":"Counts","values":213860.0,"year":2018.0},{"variable":"50–59 years","Var":"Percentages","values":0.217,"year":2018.0},{"variable":"60–69 years","Var":"Counts","values":191794.0,"year":2018.0},{"variable":"60–69 years","Var":"Percentages","values":0.195,"year":2018.0},{"variable":"70 + years","Var":"Counts","values":106349.0,"year":2018.0},{"variable":"70 + years","Var":"Percentages","values":0.10800000000000001,"year":2018.0},{"variable":"Unknown Age","Var":"Counts","values":3870.0,"year":2018.0},{"variable":"Unknown Age","Var":"Percentages","values":0.004,"year":2018.0},{"variable":"Male","Var":"Counts","values":630598.0,"year":2018.0},{"variable":"Male","Var":"Percentages","values":0.64,"year":2018.0},{"variable":"Female","Var":"Counts","values":346005.0,"year":2018.0},{"variable":"Female","Var":"Percentages","values":0.35100000000000006,"year":2018.0},{"variable":"Unknown Sex","Var":"Counts","values":8423.0,"year":2018.0},{"variable":"Unknown Sex","Var":"Percentages","values":0.009000000000000001,"year":2018.0},{"variable":"Yes","Var":"Counts","values":807451.0,"year":2018.0},{"variable":"Yes","Var":"Percentages","values":0.82,"year":2018.0},{"variable":"No","Var":"Counts","values":177575.0,"year":2018.0},{"variable":"No","Var":"Percentages","values":0.18,"year":2018.0},{"variable":"1","Var":"Counts","values":767978.0,"year":2018.0},{"variable":"1","Var":"Percentages","values":0.78,"year":2018.0},{"variable":"2","Var":"Counts","values":152422.0,"year":2018.0},{"variable":"2","Var":"Percentages","values":0.155,"year":2018.0},{"variable":"3 or more","Var":"Counts","values":64626.0,"year":2018.0},{"variable":"3 or more","Var":"Percentages","values":0.066,"year":2018.0},{"variable":"Total","Var":"Counts","values":1018776.0,"year":2020.0},{"variable":"Total","Var":"Percentages","values":1.0,"year":2020.0},{"variable":"Doctor of Medicine (M.D.)","Var":"Counts","values":917940.0,"year":2020.0},{"variable":"Doctor of Medicine (M.D.)","Var":"Percentages","values":0.9009999999999999,"year":2020.0},{"variable":"Doctor of Osteopathic Medicine (D.O.)","Var":"Counts","values":100379.0,"year":2020.0},{"variable":"Doctor of Osteopathic Medicine (D.O.)","Var":"Percentages","values":0.099,"year":2020.0},{"variable":"Unknown Degree","Var":"Counts","values":457.0,"year":2020.0},{"variable":"Unknown Degree","Var":"Percentages","values":0.0,"year":2020.0},{"variable":"United States Medical Graduates (M.D. or D.O.) and Canadian Graduates","Var":"Counts","values":783639.0,"year":2020.0},{"variable":"United States Medical Graduates (M.D. or D.O.) and Canadian Graduates","Var":"Percentages","values":0.769,"year":2020.0},{"variable":"International Medical Graduates","Var":"Counts","values":233177.0,"year":2020.0},{"variable":"International Medical Graduates","Var":"Percentages","values":0.22899999999999999,"year":2020.0},{"variable":"Unknown Medical School","Var":"Counts","values":1960.0,"year":2020.0},{"variable":"Unknown Medical School","Var":"Percentages","values":0.002,"year":2020.0},{"variable":"Less than 40 years","Var":"Counts","values":244152.0,"year":2020.0},{"variable":"Less than 40 years","Var":"Percentages","values":0.239,"year":2020.0},{"variable":"40–49 years","Var":"Counts","values":236876.0,"year":2020.0},{"variable":"40–49 years","Var":"Percentages","values":0.233,"year":2020.0},{"variable":"50–59 years","Var":"Counts","values":216873.0,"year":2020.0},{"variable":"50–59 years","Var":"Percentages","values":0.213,"year":2020.0},{"variable":"60–69 years","Var":"Counts","values":197471.0,"year":2020.0},
{"variable":"60–69 years","Var":"Percentages","values":0.19399999999999999,"year":2020.0},{"variable":"70 + years","Var":"Counts","values":120510.0,"year":2020.0},{"variable":"70 + years","Var":"Percentages","values":0.11800000000000001,"year":2020.0},{"variable":"Unknown Age","Var":"Counts","values":2894.0,"year":2020.0},{"variable":"Unknown Age","Var":"Percentages","values":0.003,"year":2020.0},{"variable":"Male","Var":"Counts","values":642960.0,"year":2020.0},{"variable":"Male","Var":"Percentages","values":0.631,"year":2020.0},{"variable":"Female","Var":"Counts","values":369139.0,"year":2020.0},{"variable":"Female","Var":"Percentages","values":0.36200000000000007,"year":2020.0},{"variable":"Unknown Sex","Var":"Counts","values":6677.0,"year":2020.0},{"variable":"Unknown Sex","Var":"Percentages","values":0.006999999999999999,"year":2020.0},{"variable":"Yes","Var":"Counts","values":843753.0,"year":2020.0},{"variable":"Yes","Var":"Percentages","values":0.828,"year":2020.0},{"variable":"No","Var":"Counts","values":175023.0,"year":2020.0},{"variable":"No","Var":"Percentages","values":0.172,"year":2020.0},{"variable":"1","Var":"Counts","values":786618.0,"year":2020.0},{"variable":"1","Var":"Percentages","values":0.772,"year":2020.0},{"variable":"2","Var":"Counts","values":159406.0,"year":2020.0},{"variable":"2","Var":"Percentages","values":0.156,"year":2020.0},{"variable":"3 or more","Var":"Counts","values":72752.0,"year":2020.0},{"variable":"3 or more","Var":"Percentages","values":0.071,"year":2020.0},{"variable":"Total","Var":"Counts","values":1044734.0,"year":2022.0},{"variable":"Total","Var":"Percentages","values":1.0,"year":2022.0},{"variable":"Doctor of Medicine (M.D.)","Var":"Counts","values":934113.0,"year":2022.0},{"variable":"Doctor of Medicine (M.D.)","Var":"Percentages","values":0.894,"year":2022.0},{"variable":"Doctor of Osteopathic Medicine (D.O.)","Var":"Counts","values":110095.0,"year":2022.0},{"variable":"Doctor of Osteopathic Medicine (D.O.)","Var":"Percentages","values":0.105,"year":2022.0},{"variable":"Unknown Degree","Var":"Counts","values":526.0,"year":2022.0},{"variable":"Unknown Degree","Var":"Percentages","values":0.001,"year":2022.0},{"variable":"United States Medical Graduates (M.D. or D.O.) and Canadian Graduates","Var":"Counts","values":803561.0,"year":2022.0},{"variable":"United States Medical Graduates (M.D. or D.O.) and Canadian Graduates","Var":"Percentages","values":0.769,"year":2022.0},{"variable":"International Medical Graduates","Var":"Counts","values":239642.0,"year":2022.0},{"variable":"International Medical Graduates","Var":"Percentages","values":0.22899999999999999,"year":2022.0},{"variable":"Unknown Medical School","Var":"Counts","values":1531.0,"year":2022.0},{"variable":"Unknown Medical School","Var":"Percentages","values":0.001,"year":2022.0},{"variable":"Less than 40 years","Var":"Counts","values":248889.0,"year":2022.0},{"variable":"Less than 40 years","Var":"Percentages","values":0.23800000000000003,"year":2022.0},{"variable":"40–49 years","Var":"Counts","values":244504.0,"year":2022.0},{"variable":"40–49 years","Var":"Percentages","values":0.23399999999999999,"year":2022.0},{"variable":"50–59 years","Var":"Counts","values":219097.0,"year":2022.0},{"variable":"50–59 years","Var":"Percentages","values":0.21,"year":2022.0},{"variable":"60–69 years","Var":"Counts","values":197215.0,"year":2022.0},{"variable":"60–69 years","Var":"Percentages","values":0.18899999999999998,"year":2022.0},{"variable":"70 + years","Var":"Counts","values":132100.0,"year":2022.0},{"variable":"70 + years","Var":"Percentages","values":0.126,"year":2022.0},{"variable":"Unknown Age","Var":"Counts","values":2929.0,"year":2022.0},{"variable":"Unknown Age","Var":"Percentages","values":0.003,"year":2022.0},{"variable":"Male","Var":"Counts","values":648521.0,"year":2022.0},{"variable":"Male","Var":"Percentages","values":0.621,"year":2022.0},{"variable":"Female","Var":"Counts","values":390416.0,"year":2022.0},{"variable":"Female","Var":"Percentages","values":0.374,"year":2022.0},{"variable":"Unknown Sex","Var":"Counts","values":5797.0,"year":2022.0},{"variable":"Unknown Sex","Var":"Percentages","values":0.006,"year":2022.0},{"variable":"Yes","Var":"Counts","values":886970.0,"year":2022.0},{"variable":"Yes","Var":"Percentages","values":0.8490000000000001,"year":2022.0},{"variable":"No","Var":"Counts","values":157764.0,"year":2022.0},{"variable":"No","Var":"Percentages","values":0.151,"year":2022.0},{"variable":"1","Var":"Counts","values":797310.0,"year":2022.0},{"variable":"1","Var":"Percentages","values":0.763,"year":2022.0},{"variable":"2","Var":"Counts","values":165751.0,"year":2022.0},
{"variable":"2","Var":"Percentages","values":0.159,"year":2022.0},{"variable":"3 or more","Var":"Counts","values":81673.0,"year":2022.0},{"variable":"3 or more","Var":"Percentages","values":0.078,"year":2022.0}]
sex_age = [{"year":2010.0,"sex":"Male","age_bin":"<40 years","pct":20.0},{"year":2010.0,"sex":"Male","age_bin":"40–49 years","pct":24.0},{"year":2010.0,"sex":"Male","age_bin":"50–59 years","pct":26.0},{"year":2010.0,"sex":"Male","age_bin":"60+ years","pct":27.0},{"year":2010.0,"sex":"Male","age_bin":"Unknown","pct":3.0},{"year":2010.0,"sex":"Female","age_bin":"<40 years","pct":37.0},{"year":2010.0,"sex":"Female","age_bin":"40–49 years","pct":29.0},{"year":2010.0,"sex":"Female","age_bin":"50–59 years","pct":21.0},{"year":2010.0,"sex":"Female","age_bin":"60+ years","pct":9.0},{"year":2010.0,"sex":"Female","age_bin":"Unknown","pct":4.0},{"year":2012.0,"sex":"Male","age_bin":"<40 years","pct":17.7},{"year":2012.0,"sex":"Male","age_bin":"40–49 years","pct":22.9},{"year":2012.0,"sex":"Male","age_bin":"50–59 years","pct":25.8},{"year":2012.0,"sex":"Male","age_bin":"60+ years","pct":31.4},{"year":2012.0,"sex":"Male","age_bin":"Unknown","pct":2.2},{"year":2012.0,"sex":"Female","age_bin":"<40 years","pct":33.6},{"year":2012.0,"sex":"Female","age_bin":"40–49 years","pct":30.3},{"year":2012.0,"sex":"Female","age_bin":"50–59 years","pct":22.2},{"year":2012.0,"sex":"Female","age_bin":"60+ years","pct":12.0},{"year":2012.0,"sex":"Female","age_bin":"Unknown","pct":1.9},{"year":2014.0,"sex":"Male","age_bin":"<40 years","pct":15.7},{"year":2014.0,"sex":"Male","age_bin":"40–49 years","pct":22.0},{"year":2014.0,"sex":"Male","age_bin":"50–59 years","pct":24.4},{"year":2014.0,"sex":"Male","age_bin":"60+ years","pct":37.3},{"year":2014.0,"sex":"Male","age_bin":"Unknown","pct":0.5},{"year":2014.0,"sex":"Female","age_bin":"<40 years","pct":30.4},{"year":2014.0,"sex":"Female","age_bin":"40–49 years","pct":30.5},{"year":2014.0,"sex":"Female","age_bin":"50–59 years","pct":22.5},{"year":2014.0,"sex":"Female","age_bin":"60+ years","pct":16.3},{"year":2014.0,"sex":"Female","age_bin":"Unknown","pct":0.4},{"year":2016.0,"sex":"Male","age_bin":"<40 years","pct":18.6},{"year":2016.0,"sex":"Male","age_bin":"40–49 years","pct":21.7},{"year":2016.0,"sex":"Male","age_bin":"50–59 years","pct":23.4},{"year":2016.0,"sex":"Male","age_bin":"60+ years","pct":35.9},{"year":2016.0,"sex":"Male","age_bin":"Unknown","pct":0.4},{"year":2016.0,"sex":"Female","age_bin":"<40 years","pct":33.6},{"year":2016.0,"sex":"Female","age_bin":"40–49 years","pct":29.2},{"year":2016.0,"sex":"Female","age_bin":"50–59 years","pct":21.1},{"year":2016.0,"sex":"Female","age_bin":"60+ years","pct":15.7},{"year":2016.0,"sex":"Female","age_bin":"Unknown","pct":0.4},{"year":2018.0,"sex":"Male","age_bin":"<40 years","pct":19.2},{"year":2018.0,"sex":"Male","age_bin":"40–49 years","pct":21.2},{"year":2018.0,"sex":"Male","age_bin":"50–59 years","pct":22.3},{"year":2018.0,"sex":"Male","age_bin":"60+ years","pct":37.0},{"year":2018.0,"sex":"Male","age_bin":"Unknown","pct":0.3},{"year":2018.0,"sex":"Female","age_bin":"<40 years","pct":33.1},{"year":2018.0,"sex":"Female","age_bin":"40–49 years","pct":28.8},{"year":2018.0,"sex":"Female","age_bin":"50–59 years","pct":20.7},{"year":2018.0,"sex":"Female","age_bin":"60+ years","pct":17.1},{"year":2018.0,"sex":"Female","age_bin":"Unknown","pct":0.3},{"year":2020.0,"sex":"Male","age_bin":"<40 years","pct":20.0},{"year":2020.0,"sex":"Male","age_bin":"40–49 years","pct":20.0},{"year":2020.0,"sex":"Male","age_bin":"50–59 years","pct":22.0},{"year":2020.0,"sex":"Male","age_bin":"60+ years","pct":38.0},{"year":2020.0,"sex":"Male","age_bin":"Unknown","pct":null},{"year":2020.0,"sex":"Female","age_bin":"<40 years","pct":32.0},{"year":2020.0,"sex":"Female","age_bin":"40–49 years","pct":29.0},{"year":2020.0,"sex":"Female","age_bin":"50–59 years","pct":21.0},{"year":2020.0,"sex":"Female","age_bin":"60+ years","pct":18.0},{"year":2020.0,"sex":"Female","age_bin":"Unknown","pct":null},
{"year":2022.0,"sex":"Male","age_bin":"<40 years","pct":20.0},{"year":2022.0,"sex":"Male","age_bin":"40–49 years","pct":21.0},{"year":2022.0,"sex":"Male","age_bin":"50–59 years","pct":21.0},{"year":2022.0,"sex":"Male","age_bin":"60+ years","pct":38.0},{"year":2022.0,"sex":"Male","age_bin":"Unknown","pct":0.2},{"year":2022.0,"sex":"Female","age_bin":"<40 years","pct":31.0},{"year":2022.0,"sex":"Female","age_bin":"40–49 years","pct":29.0},{"year":2022.0,"sex":"Female","age_bin":"50–59 years","pct":21.0},{"year":2022.0,"sex":"Female","age_bin":"60+ years","pct":19.0},{"year":2022.0,"sex":"Female","age_bin":"Unknown","pct":0.2}]
Data Detail: Physician Trends in the 2022 FSMB Census
data detail
workforce
Top 4 Trends in FSMB’s Biennial Physician Census
More than 1.4 million active licensed physicians were practicing in the U.S. in 2022—up 23% from 2010—per the Federation of State Medical Boards’ (FSMB’s) recently released biennial census (Figure 1).(Young et al. 2023) Now in its seventh iteration, FSMB’s census provides a detailed, holistic view of physician demographics, training, and licensing, linking together data from state medical boards, the National Board of Medical Examiners, American Board of Medical Specialties, and U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. This Data Detail outlines four key trends from the 2022 census and whether these trends are reflected in the current nephrology workforce.
Figure 1. Total U.S. Active Licensed Physicians 2010—2022
Trend 1: Increasing Physician–U.S. Population Ratio
U.S. Physicians
Since 2010, growth in the number of U.S. physicians outpaced the U.S. population, resulting in a 13% increase in the physician/100,000 population ratio, an important surrogate marker for physician supply (Figure 2, Figure 3). Despite the effects of COVID-19 pandemic, there were 313 physicians for every 100,000 individuals in the U.S. in 2022. Contributing to the 2022 totals were 31,504 first-time licensees, likely including the 377 newly board-certified nephrologists entering practice.(ABIM 2022) However, it’s important to note the geographic distribution of these physicians was not provided and these ratios likely vary substantially between and within regions.
Figure 2: Physician to Population Ratio 2010–2022
Figure 3: Percent Change in Physicians and U.S. Population 2010–2022
Nephrologists
Available data on the nephrology workforce (using the AMA Masterfile) for the period between 2008 and 2020 shows the specialty grew 51% (from 7,550 [2008] to 11,554 [2020]).(AAMC 2022) Using the prevalent ESRD population as a rough surrogate measure for nephrologist demand, the workforce kept pace with a prevalent ESRD population that increased 47% over this same period (Figure 4).(USRDS 2022)
Figure 4: Percent Change Nephrologists and Prevalent ESRD Population 2008–2020
Trend 2: A Graying Physician Workforce
U.S. Physicians
Nearly a third (31.5%) of U.S. physicians are ≥60 years old, and this age group has grown 54% since 2010. Similarly, mean physician age has increased from 50.7 to 51.9 years. Yet physician age differs substantively between women and men—31% of the female cohort was <40 years old and 38% of males were ≥60 years. Since 2010, there’s been a shift in the age distribution between the sexes, with more male physicians entering the oldest age quartile (Figure 5).
Figure 5: Change in Distribution of Binned Age for Female and Male Physician Cohorts
Nephrologists
In 2021 60.2% of nephrologists were <55 years (6,955 nephrologists), with 39.8% (4,596) aged ≥55 years. Additionally, this proportion of physicians <55 years among nephrologists was larger than all other medical specialties combined (53.3%).(AAMC 2022) Age data aggregated by subspecialist sex was not available.
Trend 3: Post–Matriculation Parity Yielding More Women Physicians
U.S. Physicians
Since achieving parity in medical school matriculation in 2014, the number of women physicians have increased 54%, accounting for 37% of all U.S. physicians in 2022.
Nephrologists
In 2022, 29% of practicing nephrologists (3,388 of 11,541) were women. This represents a 110% increase from 2008, outpacing the growth of female physicians overall.
Figure 6: Proportion of Women Physicians (left) and Nephrologists (right)
Trend 4: Macro Trends for Medical School Location Little Changed
U.S. Physicians
Across all physicians, the overall breakdown by medical school location has been stable with U.S. medical graduates (USMGs) comprising 76% of physicians and international medical graduates (IMGs) 22% in both 2010 and 2022 (Figure 7). Yet the composition of these two macro groups has shifted slightly with an increase in the proportion of osteopathic physicians (10.5% of all active physicians in 2022) and concurrently U.S. IMGs, who account for 67% of all Caribbean medical school graduates.
Figure 7: Medical School Location—All Physicians
Nephrologists
IMGs play a critical role in the nephrology, accounting for 51% of the current workforce and 66.2% of the pipeline.(Brotherton and Etzel 2022) Similar to physicians overall, more DOs are subspecializing in nephrology—currently 4.5% of all nephrologists and 16% of matched fellows (see the analysis of the AY 2023 Match)(Pivert 2022)—and while data are missing on practicing U.S. IMGs they made up 21% of matched nephrology fellows in AY 2023.
Figure 8: Medical School Location—Nephrologists
References
AAMC. 2022. “2022 Physician Specialty Data Report.” https://www.aamc.org/data-reports/data/2022-physician-specialty-data-report-executive-summary.
ABIM. 2022. “Initial Certification Pass Rates.” 2022. https://www.abim.org/Media/yeqiumdc/certification-pass-rates.pdf.
Brotherton, Sarah E., and Sylvia I. Etzel. 2022. “Graduate Medical Education, 2021-2022.” JAMA 328 (11): 1123. https://doi.org/10.1001/jama.2022.13081.
Pivert, Kurtis A. 2022. “First Look: AY 2023 Match.” November 30, 2022. https://data.asn-online.org/posts/ay_2023_match.
USRDS. 2022. “2022 USRDS Annual Data Report: Epidemiology of Kidney Disease in the United States.” https://usrds-adr.niddk.nih.gov/2022.
Young, Aaron, Humayun J. Chaudhry, Xiaomei Pei, Katie Arnhart, Michael Dugan, and Kenneth B. Simons. 2021. “FSMB Census of Licensed Physicians in the United States, 2020.” Journal of Medical Regulation 107 (2): 57–64. https://doi.org/10.30770/2572-1852-107.2.57.
Young, Aaron, Humayun J. Chaudhry, Xiaomei Pei, Katie Arnhart, Michael Dugan, and Gregory B. Snyder. 2017. “A Census of Actively Licensed Physicians in the United States, 2016.” Journal of Medical Regulation 103 (2): 7–21. https://doi.org/10.30770/2572-1852-103.2.7.
Young, Aaron, Humayun J. Chaudhry, Xiaomei Pei, Katie Arnhart, Michael Dugan, and Scott A. Steingard. 2019. “FSMB Census of Licensed Physicians in the United States, 2018.” Journal of Medical Regulation 105 (2): 7–23. https://doi.org/10.30770/2572-1852-105.2.7.
Young, Aaron, Humayun J. Chaudhry, Xiaomei Pei, Katie Halbesleben, Donald H. Polk, and Michael Dugan. 2015. “A Census of Actively Licensed Physicians in the United States, 2014.” Journal of Medical Regulation 101 (2): 7–22. https://doi.org/10.30770/2572-1852-101.2.7.
Young, Aaron, Humayun J. Chaudhry, Janelle Rhyne, and Michael Dugan. 2010. “A Census of Actively Licensed Physicians in the United States, 2010.” Journal of Medical Regulation 96 (4): 10–20. https://doi.org/10.30770/2572-1852-96.4.10.
Young, Aaron, Humayun J. Chaudhry, Jon V. Thomas, and Michael Dugan. 2013. “A Census of Actively Licensed Physicians in the United States, 2012.” Journal of Medical Regulation 99 (2): 11–24. https://doi.org/10.30770/2572-1852-99.2.11.
Young, Aaron, Xiaomei Pei, Katie Arnhart, Jeffrey D. Carter, and Humayun J. Chaudhry. 2023. “FSMB Census of Licensed Physicians in the United States, 2022.” Journal of Medical Regulation 109 (2): 13–20. https://doi.org/10.30770/2572-1852-109.2.13.
Citation
BibTeX citation:
@online{a._pivert2023,
author = {A. Pivert, Kurtis},
title = {Data {Detail:} {Physician} {Trends} in the 2022 {FSMB}
{Census}},
date = {2023-08-04},
url = {https://data.asn-online.org/posts/data_detail_fsmb/},
langid = {en}
}
For attribution, please cite this work as:
A. Pivert, Kurtis. 2023. “Data Detail: Physician Trends in the
2022 FSMB Census.” August 4, 2023. https://data.asn-online.org/posts/data_detail_fsmb/.